I found out this weekend that my biological father, C, is dying. He was never a healthy man. He smokes like a chimney, drinks like a fish, and is consistently inconsistent about taking the meds that control his MS. He is a workaholic, barely sleeps, and eats food that is only suitable for a trash compactor. He is 51 and has had more health maladies than an 80 year old man. He is not long for this world.
I found out this weekend he is dying, that he is on a heart transplant list and if he doesn’t shape up the next, soon approaching heart attack will most assuredly be his last.
I found out he was dying from my brother. We–a father and a daughter–haven’t talked in eleven years. He missed college, milestones, my first love. He walked away, called me a fucking cunt, cut me out of photos. He pushed me out of the family, told everyone I was to be avoided. I was a child, a strong willed, independent child, who was brave enough to stand up to a man who mentally and emotionally abused us for years. This was my punishment.
My father is dying and what I struggle with the most is how little I care. I have mourned him. I have grieved what could not be, confronted the demons that haunted me for years. To be sure my fractured relationship with him has shaped me. I am sure that without him weight would not have been such a battle, a period of promiscuity could have been avoided, and my penchant for unavailable men nipped in the bud…but it is done. No one forced my hand in to the cookie jar or down the pants of undeserving men. Years of therapy, maturity, and a wonderful, caring stepfather (who I consider to be the only real father I have ever known) have made it easier to understand him, me, and my reaction to this relationship…or lack there of.
My father is dying and I am relieved, I am ready. My head hurts but not my heart. I worry about logistics, about whether to attend the funeral of a man who never deserved the family he created. I worry about my brother. I run through scenarios in my head, how I can tactfully say “No, really, it is ok” when condolences are inevitably expressed. I wonder if, ten years from now, I will regret not speaking to him before his death. A good friend said to me yesterday “you cannot expect ill health to transform assholes”. And, my friends, my father is a lost soul. This is a man on his death bed and I have not heard a word from him. I don’t blame myself anymore; you can’t chose your parents and parental love is not one of life’s guarantees.
My father is dying and I sit here and call him an asshole…not out of anger or revenge, merely as a statement of fact. The facts, though? Sometimes they aren’t pretty.
My father is dying and he reminds me who I am…that I am strong, that I am resilient, that I have come so far. I didn’t think this would push me out of hiding. In fact, the warm cozy hole I have been hiding in beckons for me, but writing this feels right. Writing this reminds me I cannot be silenced by him, even in his life’s twilight.
My father is dying and I thank him for making me me. Despite everything, the tears, the pain, the struggles, thank you Dad. Without you there is no me.

Wow. I really don’t know what to say other than thank you for sharing this. Really.
Thank you for reading and responding.
Wow…I’m sorry to hear about your relationship with your father. My sister didn’t really have much of one with my dad, so when he died last year, it was especially hard for her since she knew she’d never get that chance.
I’m glad that you have people in your life like your stepfather who have been there for you, and you got help when you were going through those rough stretches. Right now, the best thing I can recommend is to continue to use that support system to talk about how your father’s impending death affects you. I’m here too, if you ever need someone to listen.
Leon
Thanks, Leon…and I hope your sister is doing better.
Don’t you ever, EVER take this down.
I love you so much, Lex. More than that, I admire you… And more than THAT, I am so proud to call you my best friend.
Remind me to never take this down…thank you, friend.
This is one of the things I love about you.
Your ability to work through your feelings and own them.
I do my best…thank you.
You are 100% right lady in saying he did one thing right in his life, and that is you my dear.
Don’t change, be who you are because you are a wonderful person.
I have some things I could change. For instance, I am a huge slob.
Use the funeral and months until then to support/listen to those who will grieve, like your brother. Be the helpful family member.
Thanks…and I agree. I will do my best to support.
I like bakingwithplath’s TY- you read a post about a dead/dying family and your first instance is to be really apologetic and sympathetic however when you read this it is what PQ says, it’s an out loud sorting of your thoughts and feelings.
While your relationship with your father wasn’t the best to the very least, like anybody you meet, he’s someone that’s helped you become the person you’ve been.
And for that you don’t need our “I’m sorry’s” because you are a stronger person without him and you are a stronger person because of him.
And if any of this doesn’t make sense I blame reading blogs after working til midnight.
It makes sense. Thanks for chiming in, Patrick.
WOW…all I can say is sorry for your loss. Not for the coming loss of your father, but for the loss of your father all those years ago.
Maybe it is because I have a big heart (hidden behind a brick wall), but reading this almost brought a tear to my eye. It definitely gave me a lump in my throat. Not from sadness, but from reading what all you have overcome.
Obviously you past has lead you to become the person you are today. And, from what I have read, that is a strong, independent person.
I thank you for sharing, and though I do not really know you yet, I do look forward to getting to learn more about you.
Keep your chin up and a smile on your face. Each day is only what you make it.
I do my best to keep my chin up, but sometimes I get a little cranky…it is all part of my charm.
Jesus Lem. My first reaction is to want to say “sorry for your loss”, but it really doesn’t sound like there’s much of a loss for someone to leave your life who chose not to be a part of it.
Zackly…the loss happened years ago.
Is sorry the right word if may not grieve for him? In 2007 I lost my mother. My relationship with my parents have been normal for the most part, so I can not say I know where you are coming from. But in the last days I found myself regretting not doing things with mom, since we had nearly a years warning. But that last week was impossible as she was in bed and not functional.
As a bit of advice, if you find yourself in a moment where you find yourself needing to speak to him or whatever, try to take the opportunity.
I wish the best for you and your family.
I cannot imagine wanting to speak with him, but it is pretty hard to anticipate how you may feel in the future. We shall see.
I’m not sure what’s going on today, but this is the second “loss of father” post that I’ve read in a row. Very, very different points of view, but still…..
Even when there’s no remorse, there’s still a lot of thinking, second-guessing, and “if only” conversations in your head. From our few brief conversations, you strike me as being a level-headed, strong, confident woman who knows what she wants, what she likes, and who she is. It must have been tough for you to write this, but I’m guessing that, at some level, you went with what you needed to do. Well done.
It was cathartic that is for sure.
Hey lady. Parents can be a bitch, right? Although I don’t have a similar story, I agree with you 100% about thanking him for making you you. My parents divorced when I was young, and it was bad. Really bad. But now that I’m older, I look back on those hard times that I hated so much through the years, and realize that without that, I wouldn’t be the same strong willed and independent person I am today. I actually look at people who have had easy childhoods and sort of pity them, in some weird and twisted way, for not having to go through what I did.
It’s crazy but it is really true that what doesn’t kill you makes you stronger.
Good luck in the coming months because although you feel prepared, I’m sure its going to be an emotional roller coaster.
Sometimes cliches hold some truth and I think the one about what doesn’t kill you makes you stronger is very true.
I think your friend put it really well when she (he?) said that ill health does not transform assholes.
This certainly isn’t a situation that I, as an “outsider looking in” can give much advice on.
If I were in your shoes, I’d feel a whole lot of relief. Sometimes, blood isn’t thicker than water. Yanno?
Either way, I wish you the best in figuring out where to go from here. Whatever decision you make will be the right one.
I think he had a great point…truer words…
Brought tears to my eyes. You have truly transformed a horrible experience into a beautiful lesson. Your dad didn’t intend it but he created, through biology and his abuse, an incredible woman. While I hate what he put you through, I am so glad it made you who you are.
And I am so glad you are someone I called a friend. Thanks, Zazz.
I admire and praise your strength, your honesty, your willingness to share, and your capacity for gratitude to such a man, such a father.
I want to give you a hug, buy you a drink, mail the condolence card, the usual. But… I don’t know—in a way, I feel like just reading this post and acknowledging your words and, more importantly, the wonderful woman who is YOU, is perhaps the very best show of support and love a (virtual) friend can give.
That said, sending hugs your way all the same…
Sometimes I don’t feel so strong but even a person who is scared but acts brave is brave.
Sometimes shitty people just need to be treated like shitty people. Do what’s right for YOU.
Love you, Lex.
And one more thing..
Follow your heart
Oh, my heart…it will be followed.
I think tt made a great point, and so did that good friend … be there for your brother as much as you feel you need to be, and don’t blame yourself for his shortcomings (or the fact that they aren’t magically changing now).
He is who he is who he is.
Welcome back, if only for a little while.
I think that things like this happen to remind us to make more time to be with the people that we truly love. And who love us in return. No sense in dwelling on those who would only harm.
Agreed. I think I really do cherish those close to me as a result.
You, my friend, are one of the braver people I know.
Every once in a while, amidst the poop and sex jokes, the YouTube links and memes, a post comes along that makes you feel infinitely less alone.
Thank you.
No, thank you for understanding.
I already knew you were amazing, but I’m truly floored by what you had to deal with growing up. It would have broken a lesser person.
I was looking for the right word, but I think Lilu said it best: I completely admire that strength you have.
Believe me, I am not strong all the time.
I have a strained relationship with my father. 2 years ago I decided that I would regret never having talked to him. I thought if I never told him how I felt and why i felt that way and he were to die I would live the rest of my life wishing that I had said something to him. People always tell you that not saying what you felt will be your biggest regret if you lose someone.
So I called him up, we scheduled a time to meet, and we talked. I told him everything I ever wanted to tell him. He actually shared things with me that I wouldn’t have known had we not talked. We were open with each other, we laughed, and we cried.
At then end of the long conversation I felt good about it. But the fact is that it changed nothing. He and I are no different having had the conversation, and I feel that having the talk and seeing the results confirmed in my mind that he could have died without us ever having that conversation and I think having the conversation or not having that conversation in the end won’t have made a damn bit of difference.
It simply answered that question that everyone asks: would I feel differently had I said how I felt? The answer for me is no.
My father is still alive, so I can’t say for sure, but I think for me saying how i really felt didn’t make a difference.
But you did it…and it, at the time, is what you wanted to do. So this should be commended.
Your strength is superhuman.
I had a moment a few years ago, when I asked myself a similar question: was I at the point where I wouldn’t shed a tear at my dad’s funeral? Would my brother and I be out of place as we stood there stoically, while step-brothers and step-sisters wondered why we seemed so detached from a man they apparently loved more than we did?
I made a decision that was different from yours. But not a day goes by that I don’t have the utmost admiration for people who can do what you’ve done.
But that is the thing–we all make our decisions. Glad yours was the right one for you.
Tough one. No right or wrong answers here, however you decide to handle it.
Nope, nothing easy about it.
Recall that ‘intangible’ I mentioned? I was wrong . . . it’s here quite tangibly.
Funny this comes close to Father’s Day. I lost mine in ‘06 and being adopted, he didn’t create me, but made me ‘me’ in every way, to echo your sentiment. And I guess I’ve been a bit unmade in his absence.
Thanks for the heart of the matter.
I am sorry about your loss.
I haven’t been in your exact situation, as I’m still on speaking terms with my dad. But I have a pretty good sense of what it’s like to take a hard look at your father, decide where your expectations should be (near zero) and then decide how much effort and contact you can stand (again, near zero).
I’ve found that all family relationships are complicated, but some are more than most. And only you can know what the right decision is – anyone who says you’ll have regrets, or that you should forgive, is totally full of it and has never been there. Worse, they’ve never tried to be there, or think about what it’s like.
You are among the most forgiving and charitable people I know, but when someone runs to the end of that charity, it’s best to scrape up your dignity and walk away. Good for you. I’m here for you.
Thanks Shan. Good to be reminded that I can forgive, he just is not worthy of it.
I as well have substantial father issues. Completely different, but I spoke to my father for the first time in 28 years last fall.
I appreciate the frank honesty of your post. Staring at the demons in the family closet is never easy. Thank you.
No one wants to open that closet door.
My relationship with my mom was just fine, and in late 2001 I knew she’d be gone at some point. But, instead of slowly approaching, the day appeared out of no where and I (and my family) never really got the chance to say goodbye.
Talk with him, don’t talk with him, but don’t worry about him. Do what’s best for Lem. If you have unanswered questions you need answers to, ask. But, if the price is too high, don’t put yourself in a place where the hurt with be more than the help.
Right. Protecting myself is of tantamount importance.
First and foremost: take care of youself and those you love; leave the universe to sort out the rest.
And if taking care of your brother, in this case, means helping him grieve/cope, make sure he understands that the best way he can return the favor and take care of you is to respect the limits on how much you can do that, and the valid reasons for those limits.
Sometimes I am not so great at leaving it to the universe, but I certainly try.
If I had read this post six months ago I would’ve had a hard time understanding how you can just cut out a family member like that. I have a uniquely strong bond with my family.
However, since then Nick did the same with his father and I’ve been able to maybe not understand but appreciate why. It’s -necessary- for your well being and your state of mind to NOT have him in your life. Sometimes you just need to remember that.
yes, but some bonds are strong and some are not. Glad you can see that your experience is not universal.
Darlin’, you ARE a strong woman, and I would like to say that you’d have gotten that way with or without the pain from that relationship, but you give it the meaning you need and want to. You’ll know what to do when the time comes. I truly believe that. And in the meantime, you hang onto that girl. She gives you hope and purpose. She gives ME hope and purpose sometimes, too.
I do think I will know what to do when the time comes…whats the other option? paralysis?
xoxo…
Thanks, sb.
A good friend said to me yesterday “you cannot expect ill health to transform assholes”.
Cynical as it may sound, what your friend said is basically true. Deathbed reconciliations happen a lot more on TV and in movies than in real life.
Peter
I don’t think realism as cynicism.
This is truly touching. I know the tendency is to say “I’m so sorry,” but I’m compelled to say “Congratulations.” Congratulations on the woman you’ve become.
Thanks for your congrats…and for stopping by.
You shouldn’t feel bad for not mourning him now. It sounds like you’ve already mourned for the loss of your relationship and you shouldn’t feel as if you are supposed to mourn again simply for the sake of mourning. You’re strong.
I have no interest in a dog and pony show.
That is a good friend. A good, wise friend. For a good, wise, EFFING AWESOME, person.
In short, I’m a little jels of you both. Plz hang out with me more often.
(Is it wrong that this is my reaction? Meh.)
Aw, the friend who gave that advice lives in NY, sadly.
thank you so much for sharing this. for your bravery, for the strong person you are. i admire you.
Thanks for reading…always.
Oh, sweetheart. Big hugs to you.
You are right, parental love is not a guarantee. Everyone is fucked up in their own way, and while I genuinely believe that most people do the best they can, that doesn’t mean they’re not destructive or that they’re healthy or enough for others. Good for you for taking care of you.
I agree–most people really are doing their best, but some are just not capable of anything good.
This couldnt have been an easy post to write… but I’m glad you did.
Thanks, Matt.
Sounds like you are approaching this correctly. You have identified your reaction, you are floowing your instincts, and you are not apologizing for what you will and will not do. You cannot do any more than that.
Doing the best I can, for sure.
Thus, this makes the tattoo you want on your wrist is so much sweeter!
I think so too.
You go on hiatus and come back with this bombshell?! Goddamn.
You’ve got a self awareness of exceptional rarity. Respect.
Daps.
You’re exactly right. Just because someone is dying or dies, does not erase who they really were. And I think it’s a dishonor (to yourself and to them) to forget someone’s faults just because they’re gone. Remember him for what he was. And yes, what he made you. If you don’t cry over the loss, then don’t. Just be honest with yourself about it. And it sounds like that’s what you’re doing. As for other people’s expectations, sometimes it’s easier to pretend than is to explain, but whatever you do will be fine.
I really will be fine, I know this.
All the best in the next chapter of your life, post biological father.
It has been “post” him for a while, but thank you.
this post is hard for me because my father was taken from me when i was 9 and would do anything in the world to have a father in my life.
but at what cost?
i wouldn’t want to be in your shoes because of what a jerk he was to you – it’s not fair for you to have been treated that way by your own father.
but this little part of me want to you attempt to make amends while you can. you only have one father after all.
regardless of your decision, this was wonderfully written and shows your strength.
xoxo.
I do have a father. He is married to my mother. His name is Don and he is an awesome guy.
You deserve a highfive for this. Maybe even TWO.
This is a very revealing post, very eye-opening about aspects of your personality. And I think you’re amazing for sharing this with everyone.
Can I get three high fives?
There’s not much I can add that has not already been said – take care of yourself, be there for the family members like your brother that you do care for, etc. But what I can say that is uniquely from me – is Thank you yet again for helping me put a healthy perspective on my own life. I have a very troubled relationship – not with my dad but with my mom. I tend to think of myself as a bad person because I know if I never saw or spoke to her again I would not care. Reading your post really helped me see that differently.
Nope, sometimes people are just bad…and while it may be tempting to blame ourselves, we have to do our best to avoid it.
While I’m sure this was a very difficult post for you, thank you for sharing. You said in your last post that you haven’t been proud of your writing lately. I have to tell you, this is the most amazing thing you have ever written. I wish I had even an ounce of your talent if only to tell you properly how good you are.
Congratulations for being you! I hope this was cathartic for you and you were able to arrange your thoughts.
It was cathartic and thank you so much for the nice words.
Damn. I had this image in my mind that your first new post would be a happy occasion.
This was touching and melancholic, but also uplifting. I’m not sure how well I would have coped under similar circumstances.
The events you’ve endured don’t sound like fun, but adversity has forged you into the woman you are – own it.
This could be looked at as happy…in a way.
((hugs))
My dad and I haven’t spoken in over 2 years. He has an open invite to call and apologize for the things he has said but refuses. And in the years since (and preceding) I’ve realized that it doesn’t matter anymore. Growing up it would have be nice to have a dad in every sense of the word and not a glorified sperm donor, but I can’t muster the emotion to care anymore. What is done is done and I will one day have the therapy bills to prove it.
Thanks for posting this. Makes me feel a little less alone.
Far more common that it should be, this.
We’re all dying, whether we acknowledge it or not.
Honey, you sound like you are very much making sense of a very complex, difficult relationship.
Being right doesn’t necessarily make it any easier. Call on me if you need anything I can provide.
Hey, I am doing my best…and thank you.
You go.
You go because you’re going to hear stories about him that you’ve never heard before, some of which, in small and nuanced ways, may ever-so-slightly impact way you view him as a person, if not a father. Because the questions don’t stop after people leave us. If anything they increase, and you might never get better chance to ask and listen.
You go because the people we want to understand the most are often the ones we can’t, and the frustration that comes with the inability to form the bonds we desire manifests itself in a myriad of ways, some of which can be volatile.
You go because although people speak of facts and truths, such things are invariably colored by our own perspective. And while we like to believe we’re always certain of the other person’s intents and motivations, we often aren’t.
You go because the little mental spreadsheets we keep that track all the injustices we’ve suffered at the hands of another person (with formulas, pivot tables, pie charts and the works) suddenly mean a lot less when they’re not around.
You go because as you discuss above, we are shaped as much by the rocks we break ourselves against as much at the kinder souls who encourage, teach and guide us along the way.
You go because it is a ritual as old as human history, and in this age of click-to-order individual reality, we need our human rituals more than ever. Because when it comes to family funerals, the first two words in “what’s right for you” trump the last two. There will be no Evite to this funeral, no Diggs, no Facebook surveys, none of that. For good reasons. Very good reasons.
You go because the best funerals aren’t about forgiving people unconditionally or crafting eulogies that portray them as saints, but in hoping their voice persists one last time. That you get a sense of their life as they tried to live it. A final, collaboratively-crafted sense of the person as a whole, including their flaws and misdeeds.
You go because in spite of everything, the people that usher us into this world need our help when they depart it. Because in 50 or so years, you’ll need that same help, and whether your future relationships with your own children turn out wonderful, challenging, strained, or outright lousy, one thing’s for certain – you’re going to want them there.
You go.
I will go. I don’t think–at the end of the day–he is an inherently evil person. I am capable, when I get past the disappointments, of remembering some good things from when I was a little girl. I think he failed, that he did not live up to his duties, and he is a weak man. So, yes, I will go, though I don’t know if I agree with all your reasons.
Hi. First…YOU ROCK!! I’m here, I love you, and you know I’ll do whatever you need me to do, be wherever you need me to be, and just love you cuz I do
D
I love you too…thanks so much.
I was so happy to see a new post but then I read it. I am still happy you posted, but not that you are hurting. I am sorry that things are the way they are. I admire you for the way you are processing all of this is. I know you can’t forget names you’ve been called, but you seem like a great person to me, so just remember all your friends and how much they care about you.
I do have lots of wonderful friends, you are right.
Really, why should you care? The man called you a cunt. There is no such thing as unconditional love; there are always at least the most basic conditions of being treated well.
Exactly right–no such thing as unconditional love.
Sorry if that was harsh — it just makes me so mad when grownups inflict pain upon children. You didn’t deserve that, Lex, and he now doesn’t deserve you. If you go anywhere, go only for you.
It wasn’t harsh at all; it was the truth.
I feel like anything I could say on this matter will sound trite. But I’ll try this: some people are no good and it’s best to not let them infect you with their misery. Being someone’s parent doesn’t give him a pass. Being sick doesn’t give him a pass. Being dead doesn’t give him a pass.
I know you are doing the right thing. I’ve been there (shitty parents) and I did the same thing.
Thanks for the nice words and I am sorry about your parents; even if it is nice to feel you aren’t alone, it still sucks.
I just want you to know how much I love you…how much I believe in you…and how strong and amazing I think you are.
You have endured so much and come out of it one of the most loving, kind, and interesting people I have met…not just online…but in life.
xoxo
Sounds like you mostly have a sense of peace in the way things are between you and your biological father…
the loss happened years ago.
My thought exactly. That, and this: You impress the hell out of me.
This is one of the miriad reasons I adore you and your presence in my life (ether-based though it may be). Your honesty, ingrity and courage are fucking awesome. And I’m so glad that you now have the loving and supportive family and friends that you deserve.
Btw, for my 2 cents – there is no wrong decision re: attending/not attending the funeral, unless you ignore your gut. Listen to that and remember that you are not responsible for how other people perceive your actions and/or how they choose to grieve/celebrate/process these events.
xo -em
[...] find out until this week that Lemmonex is on a hiatus as well. Sad. She came back with a post this week, but who knows when the full break will be [...]
I stumbled across this after reading your poached egg tutorial. I actually shed a tear (or nine), but I know that it wasn’t because of sympathy or pity…I guess I just understand that kind of finality and definitive let go of someone you’re supposed to love. Your post put both an underline and period on the end of how I feel/felt, I just didn’t have a way to express it. Cathartic.
It takes a wise person to know themselves so well. Good for you.
Wow, this is a truly amazing and deep post. You shared your whole life in this one little post and it does show the character and strength you have.
I totally loved this post.
All the best.
Cheers!
I can definitely understand wanting those who have hurt us so badly to be punished. But death is a rather harsh and final punishment. Have you thought about seeing him to let him have one last chance to redeem himself? Just a thought…
I’m so glad you experienced fatherly love from someone else and have had the loving support of Mama Bear all along.
Beautifully written, as always.
Best of luck to you as you go through this chapter. You are already blessed in that you have your head on straight and your emotions clarified. No matter what, you won’t be manipulated by bad relationships or self-doubt. Which, IMO, is the most important thing when you need to shield yourself.
Sometimes the things you don’t think will affect you do. I would suggest you go see him before he dusts off the planet for your sake or at least maybe a call.
”””””””””””My father is dying and I thank him for making me me. Despite everything, the tears, the pain, the struggles, thank you Dad. Without you there is no me.””””””””
””””””””””””He is a workaholic, barely sleeps, and eats food that is only suitable for a trash compactor. He is 51 and has had more health maladies than an 80 year old man. He is not long for this world.””””””””’
Jesus when did workaholic become bad is this a disney movie.
What did he do that was bad?
yes, it is a disney movie. I am dressed up as a pretty pretty princess right now.
I am sorry if this does not offer enough of an explanation for you. not every element of my life is up for public consumption. Also, if you think calling your preteen daughter a fucking cunt isn’t egregious, please go sterilize yourself.
Triple post allright. Ask him why he did what he did that you felt hurt you. Ask him all the questions you ever wanted to know about his motivations for certain things. You may be surprized at some answers. Not only what he did so much as what he wanted to accomplish by his actions.
he ABUSED us, you dick. I repeat, I will not detail the things I was subjected to here. Trust me or don’t. Your choice. I am sure he meant to control us, humiliate us, and hurt us.
Wow!!! now I feel kind of like controlling, humiliating, and hurting you. Of course I won’t.
Why I posted the third one I did not want to know. I was thinking for your benefit to go over that stuff with him so you can do the yelling and screaming at him not a stranger. Let all the emotion flow out onto him until you are tired and your voice hurts then discuss it rationally. Might want to do this by phone.
Hopefully things work out peace.